1. Xafgnosi by Wyrm has a nice full range of values, hard to do with stark black and white but it has a nice mid range incorporated with line work within the shadows of the body. Nice use of line variation, between the geometric angular straight line work and the topographical lines. great use of shape and negative space. nice utilization of focal points. great sense of depth. very intriguing composition.
2. Oops! by ChaosRipjaw has been limited to only midrange values, it lacks strong low and high values. only line use is outline. an intriguing composition. not the best use of negative space. an okay use of focal points. lack of shading makes it very flat and takes away from the sense of depth the artist tried to apply.
3. Gosh that's good! by Dragonnightwolf. not a good composition. random linework and shape, not an appealing rendering. components are just thrown together. very flat with only midtones. lacks a use of shadow, form, and highlights. no idea of negative space.
4. Opportunity Drops by afb728 was only in a midrange value, lacked low and high range values. some sense of form is present but not to the degree that the artist is sure of what theyre doing. out lined. shading does not add to the piece, or to the form of the figure. negative space was not utilized.
< Message edited by Flamehead 12 -- 3/14/2015 18:39:11 >