Forum Ranks (Full Version)

All Forums >> [AE Forum Resources] >> Forum Support and Suggestions



Message

Bealis -> Forum Ranks (1/4/2013 6:04:49)

Hello,
what about making forum ranks based on the overall number of posts on the forums? Ive seen in on some of the other forums. With us you could start with like Moglin, Zard etc..:)
Of course, if the site allowed it and spamming rules would apply.



SMGS -> RE: Forum Ranks (1/4/2013 6:34:38)

Spamming rules apply regardless anyway. I've seen certain forums use this type of system, it really wasn't pretty since all this did was encourage spam. These forums value quality over quantity, hence the titles Contructive/Helpful/Friendly/Creative are awarded to deserving members.



Grixus Faldor -> RE: Forum Ranks (1/7/2013 3:28:58)

The only distinction made is New Member and Member and to attain the latter title, one needs 25 posts, I believe, but that exists only to encourage sustained activity and the existence of titles of distinction are there to encourage users to participate and contribute to the forum positively and constructively.



N7 -> RE: Forum Ranks (1/21/2013 23:52:33)

what are the basic ranks(for a dummy).



Heroes of the Scape -> RE: Forum Ranks (1/22/2013 0:04:34)

This might be a bit outdated but this comes from [Archive] User Rating System Guide (Updated 2/13)

quote:


As for the ratings, they are:

User post ten or less - New Member
User rating <=20 - Member
User rating 21-40 - Adventurer
User rating 41-60- Helpful/Creative - Here the user may request avatar upload.
User rating 61-100-Very Helpful/Creative - Here the user may request custom title.



Grixus Faldor -> RE: Forum Ranks (1/22/2013 6:23:12)

@Heroes of the Scape: Yep, that is entirely outdated.

Titles are no longer awarded on a points basis. Aside from (New) Member, and titles awarded to contest winners, they are given to members who meet the basic requirements for that title. Of course, a nice demeanour is concomitant to the awarding of any such title. For an updated summary of the titles/ranks available, see this post: http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=12938799



Falerin -> RE: Forum Ranks (1/22/2013 18:04:23)

Not only is it outdated, it proved an unmitigated disaster when we did utilize that system. The problem with rating systems it that they either promote spam in the case of post count basis systems (further ratings drop or change unexpectedly when forum maintenance auto-deletes old threads) or they promote popularity contests in the case where users can 1 up or 1 down threads. AE very much did try such a system, it worked very poorly, and so it was discontinued. I cannot imagine we will want to try one again because our userbase has actually increased since then which makes the potential problems all that much worse.

Falerin
AE Forum Moderator
Head Mod AEGD



Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition
0.109375