Argeus the Paladin -> RE: Sacrificium- The Last Saint C&C (3/12/2013 11:10:49)
|
Now, after rereading the first chapter, coupled with this part, I found something extremely odd. Normally I would have little qualm with the WH40K elite-spam and more bullets than there are hair on your enemies' head, but consider this: Why would the 4th Reich expend such a massive amount of resources - on artillery battalion followed by a platoon of creme de la creme on a tiny band of refugee consisting of mostly children? Now, there was one explanation for this you tried to put up: In chapter 1 the Hauptmann was stated to belong to a terror-spreading unit, which at first might give the impression that they are trying to make an example of splinter refugee groups. It seems to make sense... ... until you realize that there are two possible macro-political scenarios. In both scenarios, the wanton wastage of resources are unexplainable: - If the Reich had conquered much of the known world, and Christianity (let's call a rabbit a rabbit here) is reduced to but a handful of caravans of refugees, giving them so much firework is going to be extremely detrimental. On one hand, collateral damage and all the risks associated with operating heavy ordnance. On the other, it would do a nation priding itself on might no favor for bringing serious arms to unarmed outlaws. If they win, the victory is hollow. If they lose, that's a mountain of shame right there that would do a God Emperor little good. - On the other hand, if they had not, this implies they are still meeting resistance elsewhere strong enough to withstand the juggernaught you implied. Which means they certainly cannot waste resources - guns and ammo - on a bunch of mostly harmless refugees. In either case, the best solution would have been commando and spec ops rather than artillery battalions. Independent no-fanfare, no-nonsense hunter-killer groups less than half a dozen strong that does everything from information-gathering, tracking, staling to slitting their targets' throat in their sleep. Quiet, inconspicuous, efficient, and FAR more fright-inducing "You can run, but you can't hide" while playing on the human paranoia on things they cannot see coming, compared to the lugging of heavy armament everywhere. Especially if the refugees had among them a person of great significance - you want the job done with minimal fuss and discovery chance. The problem with the amount of theatrics you put up is that, while it could appear dramatic at first sight, when you take a look at it from the logical perspective it starts to fall apart. This has the unfortunate side effect of turning your villains into the dystopian literature equivalent of cackling Saturday cartoon villain rather than being actually scary, like Janos. You would want him to be grim, and a fanatic while at the same time calculating and logical. Nothing is more frightening than a villain who's evil and who is at the same time completely sane and brutally efficient at what he's doing. (Of course, in writing this I realize it would be much, much less epic on paper. You could also handwave it that the Reich leadership is utterly nuts, but then it would call into question how they even managed to conquer so much of the known world. Unless, of course, their resources grow on trees while their enemies' don't[;)])
|
|
|
|