gwoonjustin
April 2008 Writer of the Month
|
Drums please Violins? Great, now get the entire orchestra going. Et voila! Justin hath dramatically returned! Sorry to hijack your thread for this, Fabula, but as I'm keeping my own threads locked for now, this seems as good a place as any for a quick word about my reappearance. Plus, in return you get my very first new comments! So here it goes: I'm kind of sick of not being here in L&L now, it's been enough. So I figured what the hell, lets go back. However, writing is still going as bad as the moment I left the forums. So just critisism for now; rereading some stuff, catching up on some poets and what not. I may be back as a writer too within some time, but this depends entirely on what will go on in that brain of mine, and I've yet to find the first person with the gift of understanding that weird little brat. So, as for the promised comments: I'd just finished the tanka-sets, so on with the other stuffs. The End of All Things quote:
They drown in files, their lungs are burnt; I checked all possible meanings of the word file, and none really seem to make sense. Enlighten me; which do you mean? Uhm, I'll take a stab at the meaning of the poem; seems to me like a romance between two god-like creatures comming to a dramatic end. Close, much? No doubt it is open to interpretation more than just a little bit, but one of my favorite aspects of poetry. Summary: good job! 1s and 0s Not bad, though quite unconventional, so to say. Not so much in style as in context. Wasted Shadows Wow! This may very well be your best poem ever! Really struck a note there. In fact, I disagree with Firefly here (though, admittedly, she may have been talking about a now outdated version); I think the structure supports the mood, in a way. The Demon in the Ceiling Spooky indeed, but haunting only in a good way. quote:
He takes no notes now, t-t-there are other uses for his h-h-hands. I totally get your idea here with the stuttering, but I do feel it kind of disrupts the flow... quote:
One name I should have known. This sentence to me seems to purely have been added for style, and have no meaning in the scene much. If there is a meaning behind it, please enlighten me. If not, perhaps seek a more fitting line? I too feel the angel and demon are too casually both used to describe one being. I'm fine with you changing demon to angel for the reasons you explain, but I feel you should draw more emphasis to how they are the same creature. Despite the case you made in your defence. Driven to Write quote:
on the edge of ravine. Adding "the" or "a" here seems obligatory to me. Perhaps more beautiful would be "my" but with a view to kill for, on the edge of my ravine. Stylistically I feel this poem is kind of all over the place, and not in a good way (yes, this can be good). The stanzas might need to be composed a bit more in relation to one another. Also, this being a celebration of your forum-birthday (congratulations!), it seems an awfully gloomy piece. Which is kind of a shame. Overall, you're doing great, but it all seems so extremely dark. I hope it's not as direct a reflection of you as art can be of artists. If it is, remember this little oneliner: The sweet ain't as sweet without the sour. Sounds quite lame, I know, but it actually got me through quite some stuff. This is about the quality of critisism I'm afraid you should expect from me right now; I need to get back into it, you see. That's it. My first new post. It's great to be back! I hope people can forgive me for my somewhat sudden disappearance. For what it's worth; I am awfull sorry. Well, I see there's plenty of work laying around L&L for me to sharpen my butchering knifes to, so that I may one day again butcher literature the way only butchers can. Muwhahaha. Ha. Ha. Cheerio! *skips off, throwing rose petals around*
|