RE: =DF= Approval Requests (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Artix Entertainment Games] >> [DragonFable] >> DragonFable Guides >> Pending Guides



Message


Azan -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (7/18/2015 8:58:34)

Guide: Common Game/Forum/IRC Abbreviations and Acronyms (Dragonfable version)
1. Guide Topic: A list of the abbreviations and acronyms used in the game, the forums and IRC. Totally up to date now, easier to read and navigate.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: A lot of abbreviations and acronyms are used everywhere and some people might not understand them. Plus, it was already approved and moved into the Guides, I'm just revamping it.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: Not any I can think of. Have a good day![:)]

For future reference: If you want to take over an outdated guide, you have to PM a Guides AK first to ask for permission. I will approve this, but in future, you MUST request permission, or the guide will be locked. -Hopeful Guy

Edit: Alright! Got it.




Hopeful Guy -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (7/25/2015 4:16:27)

Guide: The Ultimate DragonFable Strategy Guide
1. Guide Topic: All class based and boss-based strategy in the game.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: It's a takeover of an old guide, and it can really help people looking for strategy for a class or struggling to beat a boss.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: In a couple of days, I will move this over. Just leaving some time for objections/feedback.




Azan -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (9/13/2015 14:03:46)

Guide: Guests, Pets and Beastmasters
1. Guide Topic: There are four topics for this guide. The first one is a thorough analysis of all the Guests in the game, plus tips on using Guests. The second one is a thorough analysis of the most useful Pets in the game, plus tips on using Pets. The third one is a thorough analysis of the Beastmaster playstyle. The last one is comparing Guest Dragon and Pet Dragon.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: It provides basic information for those who do not know how to use optimally Pets and Guests. It provides useful information to determine which Pets and Guests are the most useful. It provides useful information on Beastmasters and can help people in their Stat build choice. And it can help people determine in which circumstances it's best to use Guest Dragon or Pet Dragon.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: This guide is meant as the replacement of DragonFable Guests.

Apologies for the delay! I just missed the fact that two guides were posted here on the same day. Approved and moved, and in future, you can PM one of us after 3 days to make sure we haven't just forgotten.




revan 225 -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (9/14/2015 14:29:33)

Guide: Doom Knight Codex
1. Guide Topic: Everything needed to know about Doom Knights; new and old.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: This guide gives detailed information about the old and new Doom Knight class. It provides useful information that has been tested and shown to work. It gives players who do not know the class detailed insight to the mechanics and recommended tips and information in terms of combat, stats, equipment, and so on.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: My guide has already been approved previously. I requested that I be allowed to make a new post to separate the guide for the new version of Doom Knight. Now that that is finished, I request that it be moved back over to where it was. From there I can micro update the guide as changes to the class are made.

I'll approve it, but I do recommend you go over it in the near future to double-check for spelling/grammar errors as I did spy more than one. While minor, they do detract slightly from the guide overall. ~Gingkage




RyuMandruleanu -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (11/7/2015 14:43:38)

Guide: Weapons Sorted by Power
1. Guide Topic: A listing of all weapons in DF sorted by their power
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: To provide a listing of all the weapons so everyone can find one most suitable for their class and level
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: The guide was moved back to Pending so I could add extra posts since I was hitting the size limit again

Sorry for the delay, Ryu. Approved and moved. ~Gingkage




eddyydde -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (9/18/2016 3:17:01)

Guide: All you need to know about Shadow Hunter
1. Guide Topic: Everything needed to know about Shadow Hunter
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: It provides players who do not know the class that well with detailed descriptions on how to most effectively use it
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: This is my first guide so I may have forgotten some things. I can't think of any currently

Not approved. This guide lacks in original information- the skills can be found in the pedia, strategies already exist, and the stat builds and the small skills analysis is too little to justify approving the guide. I'm sure you can work on it and produce a more detailed, refined guide, but for now, this is not approved.




Azan -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (12/4/2016 12:06:33)

Guide: All you need to know about Ninja
1. Guide Topic: Class guide for Ninja Armor.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Well, it is a class guide, and we need those. Also, it's been around since years, but the current version is completely outdated now.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: It's my fifth guide.

I see nothing wrong with this guide, so I'm approving and moving it. One small recommendation, however, is to take a look at your 'Battle Strategies' section, as the strategies do blur into each other somewhat, making it harder to follow. Perhaps consider reformatting how it's spaced? Regardless, you did a good job on this. Approved and moved. ~Gingkage

Thank you for your comment, I reformatted the spacing. Should be better now. ~Azan




eddyydde -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (5/9/2017 22:32:37)

Guide: All you need to know about Shadow Hunter
1. Guide Topic: Everything needed to know about Shadow Hunter
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: It provides players who do not know the class that well with detailed descriptions on how to most effectively use it
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: I added some extra analysis on the Q&A, stats, skills, strategies, and items and reformatted it to make the information more digeestible.

Approved and moved. ~Peachii




eddyydde -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (9/19/2017 0:08:56)

Guide: All you need to know about Master Soulweaver
1. Guide Topic: Everything needed to know about Master Soulweaver
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: It provides players who do not know the class that well with detailed descriptions on how to most effectively use it
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: This is my second guide.

Approved and moved. In future, PM an ArchKnight if there's no response after three days, to avoid unnecessary delays. -Hopeful Guy




Cedrei -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (12/29/2017 2:50:48)

Not approved. As you mentioned, there are other guides that do similar things as this list attempts to do, and being a list it does not, to my eyes, constitute as a 'guide'. To truly be a guide, it would likely require more content than what you plan on adding to this, being only a general list of an order in which to do quest chains. As such, I do not currently see the need for this guide. ~Gingkage

Guide: A Comprehensive Chronology Guide
1. Guide Topic: It's a guide listing all important events in Dragonfable in chronological order.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Dragonfable's story is often confusing and messy, especially in the sense of where one should go next. This guide will help to show new players the way through the game, without spoiling them in the process.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: There are many guides that have done similar things before. Many of them had problems (in the sense of using them to find your way through the game), and all of them are outdated. DragonFable History & Plot Synopsis gave too many spoilers to be an effective new players guide, DragonFable's Timeline was more of a release log, and Dragonfable: A Quest-By-Quest Chronology was incomplete and very cluttered. This guide aims at solving these issues, and I'm committed to keep updating it.




Sakurai the Cursed -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (7/16/2018 3:04:36)

Guide: DragonFable Stats
1. Guide Topic: An explanation of what the various stats do.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Well, I think it's just a little bit important to understand how your character functions. :P
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: There is a current guide on this topic, but it's been abandoned for a long time now and I was told to post here to get approved to take over. I've been keeping the guide up to date for a while now through having AKs edit the guide, but I've practically rewritten the whole thing and feel it would just be easier for all involved for me to take over. Feedback is welcome though!

Nice work. Approved and moved. ~Peachii




Follower -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (11/11/2021 14:25:49)

Guide: A Beginner's Guide to Pirate
1. Guide Topic: An overview of the Pirate class, including info on unlocking the class and its general playstyle.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: There are currently guides on most classes, including the Pirate, but updates and class reworks have left the Pirate guide particularly outdated. Which is a shame, as the Pirate of today is a solid class able to take on some of the game's tougher, more mechanically-demanding challenges.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: Although a previous Pirate guide exists, this isn't a takeover of the existing guide, per se -- more a wholesale new guide based on Pirate as it stands in 2021.

Best wishes.

Definitely a needed addition given how outdated the previous guide has become. Thanks for taking the time to write this, approved! [Jay]




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 3 [4]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition
0.109375