=DF= Approval Requests (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Artix Entertainment Games] >> [DragonFable] >> DragonFable Guides >> Pending Guides



Message

Ash -> =DF= Approval Requests (1/26/2012 21:57:45)

Ready to see if your guide has what it takes? Post it here, and we'll let you know!


Format to be used:

[b]Guide:[/b] <title> <link>
[b]1. Guide Topic:[/b] <topic here>
[b]2. Why I feel this guide is essential:[/b] <be as specific as possible>
[b]3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved?[/b] <Yes or No>
[b]4. Extra information or notes:[/b]

All guide approval-related discussion for a single guide should be edited into your post - no new post should be made.

In accordance to the new maximum guide rule (3b), if you are requesting approval for a sixth guide, you must say so in your application for approval.



If, after an initial declination, you believe that your guide is ready for approval, please create a new post and use the following information: 
[b]Guide:[/b] <title> <link>
[b]What has changed since the last time I asked for approval?[/b]
[b]How does this make my guide better?[/b]




Remember that you are only allowed to have 1 Pending Guide at a time, and that a guide is still pending until it has been approved and moved.

If it has been more than three (3) days since you posted an Approval Request or you have edited your Approval Request with the proper format after a declination, you may pm an AK once.

Please note that all Moderator/Archknight decisions here are final.



Therril Oreb -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (1/28/2012 11:09:04)

Guide: Alchemy for Beginners and Experts http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=19736528
1. Guide Topic: Alchemy Guide including both Health and Mana Alchemy
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Alchemy always is and was very usefull throughout the game but some tend to have problems with it. This guide should help them clearing everything out and be successful in mastering Alchemy and thus strengthening their potions.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? Yes, After many checks I see nothing that could be changed. If not approved this time I will await the result of the other alchemy guide and allow that one to continue.

Note:I started on this guide whle already an Alchemy guide was in pending. It was rather inactive and out of date back then so I planned to make my own. My apologies if this causes trouble or confusion.

Since nobody objects and the other alchemy guide is not showing any changes, I will move this guide to the guides section. ~Therril Oreb 02/02/2012



San Robin -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (2/2/2012 13:25:29)

Guide: A guide for begining/returning players http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=20044585
1. Guide Topic: Helping a starting/returning DF player get into the story by explaining things.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: A lot of people ask questions in the Q&A section about what happened or where they should begin. so this guide must be necesairy. (and I saw a request for a guide like this)
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? no, if its not aproved, I'd like to work on it some more :)

I find your guide approval worthy, but I will wait untill the other guide around the same subject is done, since it is not a race. ~Therril Oreb 02/02/2012

Approved and partially merged with other guide as agreed. ~Therril Oreb 02/04/2012



voldy27 -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (2/4/2012 5:11:12)

Guide: A Guide To ChickenCow Classes http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=19745295
1. Guide Topic: A guide on CCA nd ECCA
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: There aren't a guide for these classes so it will be a big help for players, especially the newer ones since CCA is a great class to newb(no offence)
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? Yes, this is my third try and I think that's all the information that I can add into the guide.

The guide looks good, but it misses the level 80 stats still so that should be added.
Also, the rule for a guide states that 75% must be original information, but skill sets and class images are all to be found in the Pedia.
Unless you give seperate information about the skills explaining what use they could be in a fight, I can't allow it to stay there.

Change the things I mentioned and it will be approved.
Remember to just edit your post here when you are finished. I didn't lock your thread since I am sure you can work out what I just mentioned ;)
~Therril Oreb 02/04/2012

What has changed since the last time I asked for approval? Removed the skill sets Added the battle tip section and added the lvl 80 stats. The introduction of the skills somehow merged with the strategy.
Update: The stats are also corrected.
How does this make my guide better? Players who read this guide does not need to scroll up and see what the skill does and there is a reason why this skill is good/bad.



The Cow says MOO -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (2/4/2012 5:25:20)

Guide: A guide to returning/new players
1. Guide Topic: Helping starting/returning players to go-on with the game
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: To help everyone about DF. And to group all information into one guide that suitably groups them all.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? Yes. That's because it will be San's guide approved[;)]

Just a note, check your links because this link here isn't working for me.
I will now compare the 2 guides ~Therril Oreb 02/04/2012

Merged parts with San Robin's guide as agreed. This guide removed afterwards ~Therril Oreb 02/04/2012



Faerdin -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (2/8/2012 18:48:57)

Guide: All you need to know about ChronoCorruptor
1. Guide Topic: Anything and everything that can help a growing ChronoCorruptor!
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: All Classes should have a proper Guide (Especially since the similarities and differences between ChronoCorruptor and Chronomancer may confuse some people), and I am confident that this one will answer any questions a user of ChronoCorruptor (Or person wishing to know more about the Class) could possibly have.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.

Note: Rolith expressed his discontent with ChronoCorruptor, from what I've heard. If that is the case and the Abilities are altered in any way, Shaiyal and I will be happy to update the Guide.

Since the only other Guide on ChronoCorruptor was deleted and there isn't any opposition, I will approve the All you need to know on ChronoCorruptor Guide. Guide approved and moved! -Faerdin



Hopeful Guy -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (2/17/2012 18:58:29)

Guide: A Guide on Mages
1. Guide Topic: Everything to do with the mage class!
2. Why I feel this guide is essential:: Mages can be pretty confusing, and so I created this guide
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: None

Guide not approved. Various pieces of information (Mostly in the section regarding the Mage Skill Set) were borrowed from the DF Encyclopedia, and this should not be the case. In addition, since the Guide is meant to cover everything related to Mage, it may be wise to brief the reader on underused Classes the way you have others like Doom Knight and SoulWeaver (Such as Ninja, Pirate, and Ranger). This way, the reader will have as much information as possible. -Faerdin



Hopeful Guy -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (2/19/2012 16:53:16)

Guide: A Guide on Mages
What has changed since the last time I asked for approval? Added lots more classes, improved skill analysis
How does this make my guide better?It adds more information and makes it less 'pedia orientated. This means my guide covers more topics.

Note: This is a new post because:
quote:

If, after an initial declination, you believe that your guide is ready for approval, please create a new post.

Excellent work, good sir! Guide approved and moved. -Faerdin



voldy27 -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (2/27/2012 3:28:36)

Guide: A Guide To ChickenCow Classes
What has changed since the last time I asked for approval?Adding to my last post, the stats are totally edited(finally!)and checked
How does this make my guide better? This won't players reading this guide saying things like "Hey, I still got 10 more stats to spend!". Trying to make the players as not confusing as possible.

Approved and put in the official guides. Don't forget to update if needed ;) ~Therril Oreb



Lady Aleua -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (3/2/2012 19:15:02)

Guide:
Lore's Hidden Gems - A summon gem guide http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=20127547&mpage=1&key=�
1. Guide Topic: Summoning Gems
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: To let the players know about the wonderful and helpful gems they can use to help them in their quests.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? no
4. Extra information or notes: Still in progress and will be continually updated.

Excellent work, Serenity! Guide approved and moved. -Faerdin



Troy Darksword -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (3/10/2012 12:42:32)

Guide: All you need to know about GUARDIAN ( Original by Resolute in Here )
1. Guide Topic: Class guide to Guardian Class
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: To help Dragonfable unlocking the best potential for Guardian CLass
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes:
This guide is already approved from Resolute's existing guide and was taken over by me. I will add extra information if there is more in future update

Thank You very Much.

Approved, nice work on the guide. Moved to the Guides section :) ~Therril Oreb

Thanks Sir Therril :)



Shaiyal -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (3/11/2012 4:50:11)

Guide: All you need to know about SoulWeaving
1. Guide Topic: A comprehensive guide on SoulWeavers
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Everyone could use a little help somewhere, even if they don't want to admit it ;)
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: Guide given to Faerdin and I, was already approved once in a different form.

Guide approved and moved! -Faerdin



Hopeful Guy -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (3/13/2012 13:37:18)

Guide: A Comprehensive Guide to Farming
1. Guide Topic: Everything there is to know about farming
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: It can be hard to find the best places to farm, so I'm here to help.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: Ash asked me to take this over.

Excellent work, good sir! If you wish to add more Quests in the future, please feel free to send us a PM (Or alternatively, you may post in the Update/Correction Request Thread). Guide approved and moved! -Faerdin



Onyx Darkmatter -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (3/15/2012 20:33:22)

Guide: All you need to know about Gnomish Personal Steamtank (GPS)
1. Guide Topic: How to use GPS the proper way.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Aside of it being a joke class, its offense and defense are better than Dragonlord's. Yet, not many people knows how to use this class in the right way.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: As far as I can see, this guide seems to be complete. If there's anything else that needs to be added, it will be done so in the future with some support.

Excellent work, good sir! Guide approved and moved. -Faerdin



PusatShrade -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (3/15/2012 21:11:07)

Guide: All You Need to Know about Brightmist Tower
1. Guide Topic: Shows how to complete the quest to many people that cannot.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Since nobody has made a guide for this and there were many questions on completing it, I decided to make a guide on how to complete it.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No...
4. Extra information or notes:I think this guide seems awright. Let me know if somethings missing. Peace

Guide not approved.
While Guides may be helpful and/or necessary when dealing with particularly complex or confusing Quests (Such as the 100 Room Dungeon or Togicide Quests), I feel that Brightmist Tower is fairly straightforward. It is essentially a less difficult version of Blackwyn Tomb (I believe Ghost said this in one of his earlier Design Notes posts concerning the creation of the Tower of Brightmist), and Blackwyn Tomb can be solved easily enough. If one has difficulty, they can always refer to the DF Encyclopedia for assistance. To sum things up, there simply isn't enough to Brightmist Tower for a full Guide to be created for it.
Also, please do not remove my edit again. This decision is final. Best of luck to you in the future, good sir. -Faerdin



Troy Darksword -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (3/17/2012 13:59:59)

Guide: All You Need to Know about Togslayer Class
1. Guide Topic: Class Guide
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Since Captain Rolith released this class, I make this guide to help other people to unlock Togslayer Class full Potential
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: I think, no extra information needed

Approved. Moved to Guides section. ~Therril

Thank you Very much Sir Therril



Hopeful Guy -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (4/17/2012 12:31:16)

Guide: Everything you need to know about Pirate
1. Guide Topic: A guide to the best ways to use Pirate Armor.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Plenty of players, especially people at the lower levels, use Pirate, and so we have made the guide to help them.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: This is a project between myself and Troy Darksword. It's been a pleasure working with him.

Guide approved and moved to the Guide section. Thank you for your work. ~Therril Oreb

Thanks!



Jorath -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (4/17/2012 18:39:05)

Guide: A - Z Houses and House Items ( Original guide by Silver Xoven )
1. Guide Topic: An A - Z guide of houses and house items.
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: This guide is made from the original A - Z Houses and House Items, and as it hasn't been updated, I've decided to take it over.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No.
4. Extra information or notes: No additional information needed.

Guide approved and moved. Excellent work, Leon! -Faerdin
Moved Silver Xoven's original guide. ~Leon



voldy27 -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (4/25/2012 8:05:37)

Guide: Ninja: The Sneakiest of All!
1. Guide Topic: A guide about Ninja Class
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: The ninja class has been in game for a long time but there isn't a guide about it. I hope my guide could help players who need help with Ninja.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: N/A

With the recent addition of a Pirate Class Guide, a Class Guide for Ninja definitely seems appropriate, does it not? Guide (stealthily) approved and moved! -Faerdin



Lady Greydawn -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (5/3/2012 4:58:12)

Guide: A-Z Dragon Coin Items http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=20279183&mpage=1&key=�
1. Guide Topic: All Dragon Coin Items
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: This guide will make it easier for players to find any Dragon Coins Items, as they are all in one place. It is faster and easier than going to several different guides to find what they are looking for.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: The original guide was not being updated, so I was given the chance to take over ownership, and have worked hard get it updated.

Excellent work, Lady! Should you need to update the Guide, you are always welcome to. Guide approved and moved! -Faerdin



the_hated_one -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (5/12/2012 1:28:47)

Guide: A simple warrior guide for Newbie http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=20310032
1. Guide Topic: A guide for warrior
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: because most character starts with warrior, and i observed that there is no warrior guide yet.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No, i would like to improve it if it will get denied.
4. Extra information or notes: N/A


Guide not approved.
As is dictated by the Rules of the Dragonfable Pending Guides Forum, 75% of all information included in a Guide must be completely original. This is why Class Guides, particularly those concerning the Base Classes, are a formidable undertaking from the beginning. The majority of this Guide is made up of the Warrior Skillset, and a great deal more information should be offered, else a player could simply look through the DF Encyclopedia to find what they need.
In addition, since this Guide concerns the Warrior Base Class, it would be for the best if information applicable to players of all levels was included. This would mean adding Stat Builds for players below level 30 and including more thorough information on Classes usable by Warriors. Warrior Equipment should also be expanded upon, as Warriors may require more than Weapons for their arsenal and seek an expert opinion.
On a final note, Credits should be more specific (What did these Forum Members contribute toward your Guide?) and your banner exceeds the amount of pixels allowed, which is 500x500. Best of luck when working on this Guide in the future, good sir. -Faerdin



RyuMandruleanu -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (5/14/2012 23:31:01)

Guide: Bonus and Resistance Guide (Previous version by Amboo)
1. Guide Topic: A listing of all DF accessories based on the bonuses/resistances that they give
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: Update of a guide that's been inactive for a long time. Useful as a reference for people that want to adjust their equipment with the maximum amount of a bonus/resistance whenever they need to that they feel will improve their play
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: None I can think of

Before I can approve this, I want to ask you 1 thing and suggest 1 thing that might improve the userfriendlyness of the guide.
Will this only hold accessories or will you add weapons later on? Since the previous guide did have weapons also in it so asuming you remade and updated the guide, not putting weapons in it does make a difference since it too is an important part of the quipment.
I would also advice a different way for us to quickly move in the guide. Right now, I have to click the link, which opens in a new tab/window for me, then it takes quite a bit to load and since the elemental resistances are grouped together in 3 parts, I have to scroll all the way up to the correct element I want.

You don't have to add weapons, but I would highly recomend you change the moving through the guide system. Using tags and ctrl+f system being used in most guides would be a lot better (you can check other guides if you are not certain). You can edit your post here with your final answer and a DF Guides AK will then give a decision.
~Therril Oreb


EDIT: I actually have a search function in place right now, though I may wish to make it more transparent that each of the bonuses is surrounded by {} (listed right above where the links are). I wasn't planning on adding weapons, since most of the time that changes based on what you want to use offensively. It also would make some of the posts (Crit especially) overflow since the majority of the ~4000 weapons have a lot of similar stats

EDIT2: Bolded the line explaining my search function and added a 'Table of Contents' header

Approved and moved to the guides section, thank you very much for your work. ~Therril Oreb



Lady Greydawn -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (5/15/2012 8:06:39)

Guide: A-Z Dragon Amulet Items
1. Guide Topic: Dragon Amulet Items
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: This guide will make it easier to find any Dragon Amulet item that a player may be looking for (or just look to see which items are DA only) without having to search through a lot of different guides.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes: I just felt that other players might find this guide helpful, especially if (like me) they don't always have time to search through several guides to find good DA items.

Just like in the approval request above, I would advise a different moving through the guide system. Though the loading time is less long, you still open in a different tab or window.
Aside from that, everything seems to be in order and following the rules. So if you do not wish to change the moving trough the guide system, just edit it in this post here and a DF Guides AK will handle the approval of the guide.
~Therril Oreb

Edit: Since the way I use for moving through my guide is not against the rules, and other guides do use the same way; I think I will leave it the way it is. I believe I do explain how to use Control+F to look for specific items...in the About This Guide section...if not, I will add it since I planned to have it in the guide anyway.

Regardless, A-Z Dragon Amulet Items looks lovely. Guide approved and moved! -Faerdin



Alyksandrei -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (5/22/2012 15:23:24)

Guide: Dragonfable: A Quest-By-Quest Chronology http://forums2.battleon.com/f/tm.asp?m=20334932
1. Guide Topic: A (mostly) chronological listing of quests, answering the question, "What order should I do the quests in?"
2. Why I feel this guide is essential: As a returning player after several years, I found myself overwhelmed by the number of new quests . . . and wondering what order they belonged in for the story to make sense.
3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No. I wish to improve it.
4. Extra information or notes: 1. I don't think I have all the most recent walkaround quests (I have none from Aika Village; there may be other areas with walkaround quests that weren't listed in the A-Z Locations, Quests, Wars & Events guide I used) 2. I do plan on including seasonal/holiday/special-event quests, but I haven't gotten that far yet. If final approval depends on including these, then I'll just get busy adding them now. Otherwise I think I'll wait a day or two, just to let my vision clear (I've been staring at this for nearly a week . . . everything's all black-and-white lines of text). 3. Whether or not it gets approved, Alina seems to think it was useful. Got a pm just after I posted it. It's been tweaked a bit now, though.

Thanks for reviewing my guide!

While the Dragonfable Quest Guide is currently being revamped, I believe both Guides can coexist peacefully (The Quest Guide contains specific details on Quests and lists them in an A-Z format while this Guide lists them in chronological order). After all, they both serve different purposes. Guide approved and moved! -Faerdin



Troy Darksword -> RE: =DF= Approval Requests (5/25/2012 7:19:02)

Guide: A-Z Abilities and Overview of Classes
1. Guide Topic: List of Classes Ability and overview of each classes
2. Why I feel this guide is essential:

This guide is best for helping people searching for classes in the DF Encyclopedia so they can decide which is the best classes for them or which classes suite them most. I have updated it with the latest classes.

3. Do I wish my guide to be locked if not approved? No
4. Extra information or notes:

This guide was originally make Archmagus Orodalf ( Original Guide Link ) in DF Encyclopedia : Classes and Ability Section. And was taken over by Therril and next it was taken over by me.

Thank You Very Much

Guide not approved.
One minor note would be that, as the original owner of this Guide, ArchMagus Orodalf should be credited as the Original Owner while Therril Oreb should be credited as a Previous Owner. The main issue, however, is that A-Z Abilities and an Overview of Classes has a considerable amount of spelling errors. For example, the Pactagonal Knight Class is spelled "Pactoganol Knight." Once you've thoroughly looked through your Guide and eliminated these errors, I will approve your Guide. -Faerdin

Thank you very much Sir Faerdin. Correction is under Progress -Troy Darksword

Guide: A-Z Abilities and Overview of Classes
1. What has changed since the last time I asked for approval?

  • Death Link replaced
  • Spelling and Granmar Corrected
  • Corrected the wrong MP of each classes
  • Typo Corrected
  • Archmagus Orodalf Credited as Original Owner


2. How does this make my guide better?

The guide has been improved as listed above. I really wanted to thank all people supported me in making this uide

3. Extra information or notes:

This guide was originally make Archmagus Orodalf ( Original Guide Link ) in DF Encyclopedia : Classes and Ability Section. And was taken over by Therril and next it was taken over by me

Thank you very much

First, I've merged your posts to prevent double posting. When edits have been made on your Guide and you wish to apply for approval once again, all you must do is edit your original post. If an ArchKnight or Moderator does not respond within three days, you may send a Private Message as a reminder.
Now, on to your Guide. I daresay you've risen to the occasion; many corrections have been made and typos are almost non-existent. A job well done indeed. Guide approved and moved to the DF Encyclopedia! -Faerdin

Thank you very much Sir Faerdin.



Page: [1] 2 3 4   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition
0.140625